Matt Taibbi’s Take On “White Fragility”

by William Skink

With cancel culture on steroids, the book White Fragility is getting a new surge of attention. Matt Taibbi is mystified by this because he has read the book and clearly understands how blazingly racist anti-racists can be. Here are some excerpts:

DiAngelo isn’t the first person to make a buck pushing tricked-up pseudo-intellectual horseshit as corporate wisdom, but she might be the first to do it selling Hitlerian race theory. White Fragility has a simple message: there is no such thing as a universal human experience, and we are defined not by our individual personalities or moral choices, but only by our racial category.

If your category is “white,” bad news: you have no identity apart from your participation in white supremacy (“Anti-blackness is foundational to our very identities… Whiteness has always been predicated on blackness”), which naturally means “a positive white identity is an impossible goal.”

DiAngelo instructs us there is nothing to be done here, except “strive to be less white.” To deny this theory, or to have the effrontery to sneak away from the tedium of DiAngelo’s lecturing – what she describes as “leaving the stress-inducing situation” – is to affirm her conception of white supremacy. This intellectual equivalent of the “ordeal by water” (if you float, you’re a witch) is orthodoxy across much of academia.

Yes, in three paragraphs Taibbi referenced both Hitler and anti-witch hysteria. Here’s more:

DiAngelo’s writing style is pure pain. The lexicon favored by intersectional theorists of this type is built around the same principles as Orwell’s Newspeak: it banishes ambiguity, nuance, and feeling and structures itself around sterile word pairs, like racist and antiracist, platform and deplatform, center and silence, that reduce all thinking to a series of binary choices. Ironically, Donald Trump does something similar, only with words like “AMAZING!” and “SAD!” that are simultaneously more childish and livelier.

With the Trump comparison Taibbi has hit the trifecta.

DiAngelo sounds just like the people lecturing City Council last week about how Missoula needs to decenter its whiteness. If readers recall, this effort is going to take taxpayer money and the growth of local government by creating a new job position.

Getting back to Taibbi’s piece, the most offensive example he cites is DiAngelo’s interpretation of how Jackie Robinson broke the race barrier in baseball. Here is DiAngelo’s take:

The story of Jackie Robinson is a classic example of how whiteness obscures racism by rendering whites, white privilege, and racist institutions invisible. Robinson is often celebrated as the first African American to break the color line…

While Robinson was certainly an amazing baseball player, this story line depicts him as racially special, a black man who broke the color line himself. The subtext is that Robinson finally had what it took to play with whites, as if no black athlete before him was strong enough to compete at that level. Imagine if instead, the story went something like this: “Jackie Robinson, the first black man whites allowed to play major-league baseball.”

And here is Taibbi’s takedown:

There is not a single baseball fan anywhere – literally not one, except perhaps Robin DiAngelo, I guess – who believes Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier because he “finally had what it took to play with whites.” Everyone familiar with this story understands that Robinson had to be exceptional, both as a player and as a human being, to confront the racist institution known as Major League Baseball. His story has always been understood as a complex, long-developing political tale about overcoming violent systemic oppression. For DiAngelo to suggest history should re-cast Robinson as “the first black man whites allowed to play major league baseball” is grotesque and profoundly belittling.

Robinson’s story moreover did not render “whites, white privilege, and racist institutions invisible.” It did the opposite. Robinson uncovered a generation of job inflation for mediocre white ballplayers in a dramatic example of “privilege” that was keenly understood by baseball fans of all races fifty years before White Fragility. Baseball statistics nerds have long been arguing about whether to put asterisks next to the records of white stars who never had to pitch to Josh Gibson, or hit against prime Satchel Paige or Webster McDonald. Robinson’s story, on every level, exposed and evangelized the truth about the very forces DiAngelo argues it rendered “invisible.”

It takes a special kind of ignorant for an author to choose an example that illustrates the mathematical opposite of one’s intended point, but this isn’t uncommon in White Fragility, which may be the dumbest book ever written. It makes The Art of the Deal read like Anna Karenina.

Read Taibbi’s whole article, it’s worth it.

About Travis Mateer

I'm an artist and citizen journalist living and writing in Montana. You can contact me here: willskink at yahoo dot com
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Matt Taibbi’s Take On “White Fragility”

  1. john mcnaught says:

    Good blog William. I think there is hope for the next generation. To paraphrase : the arc of the moral universe is long but it bends towards justice. You can’t see it but is a matter of conscience.
    Polemics like these are very useful if not valuable.

  2. S Brennan says:

    “There is not a single baseball fan anywhere – literally not one, except perhaps Robin DiAngelo, I guess – who believes Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier because he “finally had what it took to play with whites.” …For DiAngelo to suggest [this] is grotesque and profoundly belittling.”

    Indeed, the misrepresentation of history to suit ones needs has become common with writers seeking aclaim…it’s as if those made to contemplate1984 in school assumed it to be an instruction manual.

  3. Big Swede says:

    Let have a conversation about baseball or better yet racist America while ignoring the real evil in this world.

    Short Video on the link.

Leave a Reply